How to Negotiate a New Roof When Buying a Home in 2025?

Imagine you have finally found the house of your dream and you are ready to buy it! But here is the thing: its roof has issues. maybe it’s leaking or needs some fixing or even replacement! This could be quite disappointing.

This is why, when you are buying a house with an old roof, you should think about negotiating with the seller to fix it, especially if you notice that something is out of order.

However, as a buyer, you will want to understand better what you might find on the roof inspection report. Like this, you will be able to avoid paying for the roof and can negotiate a new roof after inspection.

How to negotiate this issue when buying a house that needs a new roof?

This is what we are going to talk about today. You will find out what factors and nuances should be taken into consideration before you buy a house with an old roof. Also, we will explain how you could negotiate a new roof with the seller. And finally, you will get a couple of handy tips should you face difficult owners!

Buying a House With a Bad Roof. Things You Should Know

If you need to negotiate a house’s roof replacement or repair, you will basically need to get an independent roofing inspection. Afterward, you will need to consult with your real estate agent or home inspector and offer a 50/50 split of the costs to your seller. However, there are other details involving a new roof negotiation we suggest you take a look at below.

Buying a House with an Old Roof – What to look for

When you decide to buy a house, you have preconceived notions about what you want and how you want it. Also, you have created a budget. This is why, if you realize that your future home’s roof needs repairs, you understand that it means additional expenses. But since the roof is an important part of any house, you can’t just close your eye on it!

This is why getting to know the condition of the roof before making an offer might be a good idea. As an option, you can also request a roof inspection and notions of repairs or new roof needs. Luckily, we can recommend you some great ways to determine if a roof has damage that needs repairing or replacing:

Check the records with the local municipality. Make sure the permit has been issued the last time a roof was installed on this house. You will know easily if a roof is 10 or 15 years old or even older

If there are gutters and downspouts attached to the roof, you can check for shingle pieces in the gutters. With the flow of time, asphalt shingles will degrade and break down and as it rains, these particles can get washed into the gutters

• Check the flashings on the roof. They are meant to seal the seams of your roof so you don’t get leaks. If your roof has tar or cement flashings, they should be replaced with metal ones for longer durability
• Look for any discoloration or staining on the ceilings of the home
• Pay close attention for water damage while you are walking through the home
• Check the roof from the exterior for moss, warped shingles, shingles that are missing, and any other obvious signs of roof damage!

However, it can happen that none of this makes sense and you still are not sure what you need to know. If this is the case, call your local home inspection team.

They will come out to conduct a complete roof inspection on your behalf. It will be more effective and besides, more professionally done! And remember that messing up on roof issues can cost you a lot of money if you notice any flaws after you make the home purchase!

monkeybusiness via VistaCreate

Tips For Negotiating a New Roof Before Selling/Buying a House

If you are selling (and especially buying!) a house with an old roof that needs any repairs, you need to know how to negotiate a new roof installation, as well as any repairs that might be needed for the current roof.

But since a negotiation can become a very tricky thing! See, when a roofing company gets involved with the home selling/buying process, you will need to agree with the seller on how and when the roofing company is paid.

Of course, it is normal that, as a home buyer, you will typically accept certain items that show up on the inspection report. It mostly happens because you want to buy the house and don’t want to miss out. But you might still want to get the seller to pay for the roof replacement or fixing fully.

Typically, part of this agreement involves the percentage of how much the seller pays vs how much the buyer pays. The goal of a buyer is to get the seller to agree to a 100% purchase of a new roof. However, the tricky thing is that this typically is not in the seller’s best interest!

This is why below you can find some useful recommendations on this subject. But the most important aspect will be hiring/consulting with a real estate agent that has a high rating or with a home inspector! We suggest you take a look at how it might be to negotiate a new roof when buying a home:

• As mentioned above, how and when the roofer gets paid. In some cases, the company will agree to wait until closing to get paid
  Consider how much the buyer or seller will pay for the new roof. Most buyers would expect at least a 50/50 split, if not more. If the seller is desperate for the sale, he or she would offer a reduced asking price for the exchange of new roof installation
• If you are able to agree on a new roof replacement before closing occurs, make sure that you get to choose the roofing company, type of roof, and the roofing materials that you want! Like this, you will get a job of high quality done by the roofing company that replaced the roof
• Get an independent roof inspection by the home inspection team you choose. This will allow you to compare the results of the inspection made by your team with those of the seller’s roof inspection team
• Your real estate agent should be able to ensure that, whatever the solution, it is written and legally binding. It will guarantee that, after you buy the home, your seller won’t suddenly refuse to provide you with the cash for the roof!

And finally, the last piece of advice we want to give you is this: always consider the warranty! Some roofing warranties from the manufacturer and the roofer are non-transferable. This means that if the current homeowner buys the roof, you may not be entitled to warranty coverage after you take ownership of the home!

If this is the case, it may be wiser for you to get the cash from the seller, or as an option, you might want to reduce the home value, and then handle the roof replacement yourself.

VitalikRadko via VistaCreate

What to Do If You Have to Deal With Difficult Homeowners?

When you buy a house, you have to communicate with its current owner anyway. And of course, it’s good if your home seller is an adequate person who is easy to agree with and deal with. However, not everyone is so lucky! Some homeowners are very reluctant to get a roof replacement or cover the cost of one.

But you should not get upset! It can be possible to convince them if you talk about the roof like other major systems of the home, such as plumbing, electrical, sewage, etc. The roof is there not just for an aesthetic purpose, it is something the home needs in order to be functional!

5 tips on how to deal with difficult landlords

Also, you can ask your real estate agent to suggest that the home is likely to be harder to sell now that the roof issue is known about. Quite a few sellers will want to find out what a huge impact a poor roof can have on the value of their home! By the way, there are not so many homeowners that might still want to restart the selling process with new buyers, knowing that they will have to confront the roof issues again anyway.

It may also be helpful to get a quote on the roofing replacement. Knowing what a roof replacement will cost is helpful for both you and the seller to understand their options. Of course, make sure you either get a quote from a specific roofer you fully trust or from three qualified roofers!

We would recommend you opt for the second variant since, as there will be two parties that take a decision, it is best to get three quotes. Like that, neither party will feel that they have been manipulated.

Also, should you need to repair or replace the roof of the house you’re buying, note that the quality of the roofing materials is likely to be a stumbling point between you and the seller! That’s because as a future owner of the house, you want a roof that is of high quality and will last for years. But the seller usually just wants the bare minimum! This is why, when you get the quotes from the roofers, ask them to also provide a few for different quality materials.

Typically, you will have a better argument for premium materials if the roof already has premium materials, as it is essentially a replacement cost. However, be ready that the sellers will insist on installing only 3-tab shingles or basic materials. This is why quotes from the roofers are needed!

Plus, it is important to understand that the current homeowner could have replaced the roof with 3-tab or other basic roofing materials before they put the house up. You can’t expect them to cover the full cost of premium materials unless that is standard for your neighborhood.

So, now you know more about how to negotiate a new roof or a roof repair when you are going to buy a new house. With the help of this information, you will now be able to imagine what to expect from your house sellers and how to react to their demands or requests.

Also, now you know a few handy tips that will allow you to negotiate the most comfortable price of a roof repair for you.

IgorTishenko via VistaCreate

The Only Samples You Need

Ever wished paint sampling was as easy as sticking a sticker? Guess what? Now it is! Discover Samplize's unique Peel & Stick samples. Get started now and say goodbye to the old messy way!

Get paint samples